From my perspective!

First, we use Magd's WhatsApp Gateway, so we follow their Terms of Service, including the Marketplace policies. They even regularly post updates to this forum. This is excellent.
Second, the marketplace operates centrally within Magd, so it makes sense. Even when a plugin is removed from the marketplace, we're notified in this forum.

18 minutes ago, Arthur Leywin said:

From my perspective!

First, we use Magd's WhatsApp Gateway, so we follow their Terms of Service, including the Marketplace policies. They even regularly post updates to this forum. This is excellent.
Second, the marketplace operates centrally within Magd, so it makes sense. Even when a plugin is removed from the marketplace, we're notified in this forum.

Of course, no one is thinking about rejecting the Terms of Service. You're overthinking it.

This is simply about understanding how the marketplace system works so users know and can take the necessary actions.

For example, users who use MPWA as a SaaS can inform their members/ subscribers that plugins may disappear at any time and become unusable. That way, if a plugin becomes unavailable in the future, the SaaS owner won’t be blamed.

17 minutes ago, Ipo Kane said:

Of course, no one is thinking about rejecting the Terms of Service. You're overthinking it.

This is simply about understanding how the marketplace system works so users know and can take the necessary actions.

For example, users who use MPWA as a SaaS can inform their members/ subscribers that plugins may disappear at any time and become unusable. That way, if a plugin becomes unavailable in the future, the SaaS owner won’t be blamed.

If you sell SaaS, your users know the service is yours. If a plugin goes missing, it's a business risk for you, having chosen an infrastructure controlled by another programmer. Avoiding "member blame" by shifting responsibility to the lead programmer is somewhat unethical.

In any ecosystem (Play Store/App Store/WP), developers have the right to withdraw their products. The difference here is that the main programmers are honest and transparent in the forums.

If you want your members to be safe and not feel like they're losing out, you should code your own plugin locally so you don't have to rely on a centralized marketplace.

4 minutes ago, Arthur Leywin said:

If you sell SaaS, your users know the service is yours. If a plugin goes missing, it's a business risk for you, having chosen an infrastructure controlled by another programmer. Avoiding "member blame" by shifting responsibility to the lead programmer is somewhat unethical.

You clearly don’t understand what I’m saying.

Is there any sentence from me that states I’m shifting responsibility to the programmer?

If a plugin disappears, that is indeed the SaaS owner’s risk. But that risk should not be passed on to members/subscribers either—that’s why it’s necessary to inform them that a plugin may become unavailable at any time. In fact, that is a responsible action toward members/subscribers.

And understanding how a marketplace works is a way to minimize business risk. Is there anything wrong with that?

Of course, developers have the right to withdraw their plugins.
Marketplace systems work differently. In WordPress, when a developer removes a plugin from the repository, plugins that are already installed on users’ servers are not deleted. Are you aware of that?

If it works differently in MPWA, then there’s no problem at all. That is entirely the developer’s right, and everyone must comply with the MPWA marketplace terms of service.

This is just a simple matter: how the marketplace system works. That’s all. Do you understand?

I don't sell SaaS by the way.

Edited April 30Apr 30 by Ipo Kane

8 hours ago, Ipo Kane said:

I think the key issue is whether a plugin that has already been installed can be removed by the developer. In other words, does the user not have full control over the files that are already installed and exist on their own server?

What if a user heavily depends on a particular plugin for their business, and then it is suddenly removed by the developer? That would certainly be concerning 🙏

8 hours ago, Arthur Leywin said:

Just by looking at the number of people using the plugin, it's clear that the marketplace has control and knows the number of servers or shared hosting providers using the plugin.

Plugin developers cannot delete or modify any plugin installed by users.
No plugin is published in the marketplace until it has been fully reviewed.

The plugin was removed during the update to version 14.2.1. Understood?

The marketplace does not store anything, you only download from it. It only count installation.

With every update, files are added and others are removed, just like in previous versions. As done with Autoreply and the themes system, they were removed during updates because they were no longer necessary.

The same happened in the latest update. Any user who had installed this plugin had it removed because it was causing conflicts with other plugins. No conflicting code is allowed within the MPWA project, so it was removed. Once the developer finishes updating it, it will be uploaded again to the marketplace and can be installed.

2 minutes ago, Magd Almuntaser said:

Plugin developers cannot delete or modify any plugin installed by users.
No plugin is published in the marketplace until it has been fully reviewed.

The plugin was removed during the update to version 14.2.1. Understood?

The marketplace does not store anything, you only download from it. It only count installation.

With every update, files are added and others are removed, just like in previous versions. As done with Autoreply and the themes system, they were removed during updates because they were no longer necessary.

The same happened in the latest update. Any user who had installed this plugin had it removed because it was causing conflicts with other plugins. No conflicting code is allowed within the MPWA project, so it was removed. Once the developer finishes updating it, it will be uploaded again to the marketplace and can be installed.

Clear @Magd Almuntaser . Thank you for the explanation.

2 minutes ago, Ipo Kane said:

Clear @Magd Almuntaser . Thank you for the explanation.

So finally you get the correct answer from Owner. 😁👍
Because plugin developer doesn't have permission to delete those files on your server...

Edited April 30Apr 30 by Dammah

Just now, Dammah said:

So finally you get the correct answer from Owner. 😁👍
Because plugin developer doesn't have permission to delete those files on your server...

Yes 😁

Previously, I also assumed that plugin developers don’t have permission to delete those files on the server. I just wanted to make sure how the marketplace works, because the auto removal of the @Oworock plugin is also a concern for me. It’s clear now that it happened due to a conflict and the plugin was removed during an update.

I hope this topic does not continue to be discussed extensively. In short:

With each update, services are added and others are removed. You can check the releases notes and you will find entries like “Removed bla bla bla.”, "Added bla bla bla", "Fixed bla bla bla"

As the developer of this script, when a feature is no longer needed in the script, it gets removed, such as Autoreply and the themes system.

The plugin (coexistence) had issues that caused most other plugins to stop working. It was necessary to release version 14.2.1 to remove this plugin from users because it was creating compatibility problems. Otherwise, this forum would be flooded with complaints, reports that MPWA is not working, and numerous private messages.

The solution was to remove the plugin with the new update, and that is exactly what happened. There are no privacy violations. Since the script is free, I, as the developer, have the right to remove or add any feature I consider appropriate.

This discussion should not be prolonged. If there are doubts about (MPWA), another script can be used. The work here is done voluntarily, and (MPWA) takes significant time and effort without any compensation. Focus should remain on improving (MPWA) into something greater.

3 minutes ago, Magd Almuntaser said:

I hope this topic does not continue to be discussed extensively. In short:

With each update, services are added and others are removed. You can check the releases notes and you will find entries like “removed bla bla bla.”

As the maintainer of this script, when a feature is no longer needed in the script, it gets removed, such as Autoreply and the themes system.

The plugin (coexistence) had issues that caused most other plugins to stop working. It was necessary to release version 14.2.1 to remove this plugin from users because it was creating compatibility problems. Otherwise, this forum would be flooded with complaints, reports that MPWA is not working, and numerous private messages.

The solution was to remove the plugin with the new update, and that is exactly what happened. There are no privacy violations. Since the script is free, I, as the developer, have the right to remove or add any feature I consider appropriate.

This discussion should not be prolonged. If there are doubts about (MPWA), another script can be used. The work here is done voluntarily, and (MPWA) takes significant time and effort without any compensation. Focus should remain on improving (MPWA) into something greater.

MPWA is great. And you have worked hard developing, maintaining, and now even reviewing every plugin in the midst of your daily busy schedule.

From the beginning, there has never been any doubt—this was just bringing up someone’s concern, which is also quite interesting, regarding how the marketplace works.

Thank you for your hard work, all the sacrifices, dedication, and generosity.

Go go MPWA! 💪

Coming very soon: Plugin MP-Commerce
Full e-commerce system with storefront, cart, checkout, orders, shipping, payments, and WhatsApp notifications.

============



============



===========



==========



========



===========



==========



===========



============

4 minutes ago, Magd Almuntaser said:

Coming very soon: Plugin MP-Commerce
Full e-commerce system with storefront, cart, checkout, orders, shipping, payments, and WhatsApp notifications.

============



============



===========



==========



========



===========

change to orange mister @Magd Almuntaser 🤣👍

@everyone how to make funnel marketing

landing page -> capture leads-> whatsapp Sequence follow up

if using plugin Sequence Messaging or leads capture trigger came from first chat base on keyword

if using LP builder which combination plugin to connected automation whatsapp Sequence follow up

any suggestion which combination plugin shoul used?

4 hours ago, pinpin said:

@everyone how to make funnel marketing

landing page -> capture leads-> whatsapp Sequence follow up

if using plugin Sequence Messaging or leads capture trigger came from first chat base on keyword

if using LP builder which combination plugin to connected automation whatsapp Sequence follow up

any suggestion which combination plugin shoul used?

Soon, please wait. Under development.

On 4/30/2026 at 2:32 PM, Magd Almuntaser said:

try to restart nodejs ..

Have restarted many times,, but same issue,, can you please help

@Magd Almuntaser Hi,

I'm facing an issue with my admin dashboard. The CPU and RAM usage are not showing at all — it displays "-- MB" instead of actual values.

Also, the admin homepage is loading very slowly. Node.js seems to be running in the background, but the system resources (CPU/RAM) are not being detected or displayed.

The troubleshoot section shows everything is valid (SSL, cURL, Node config), but still the resource stats are missing.

Could you please check if there is any issue with the server monitoring service, Node integration, or API fetching system stats?

Please fix this as soon as possible.

Thank you.

cannot access AI BOT..

3 hours ago, GNJ said:

Have restarted many times,, but same issue,, can you please help

Do you use aaPanel?
Or cPanel?
Because if you are using aapanel + nginx, you should follow the explanation on YouTube:
https://youtube.com/@magdalmuntaser/videos

1 hour ago, RN Funny Chanel said:

@Magd Almuntaser Hi,

I'm facing an issue with my admin dashboard. The CPU and RAM usage are not showing at all — it displays "-- MB" instead of actual values.

Also, the admin homepage is loading very slowly. Node.js seems to be running in the background, but the system resources (CPU/RAM) are not being detected or displayed.

The troubleshoot section shows everything is valid (SSL, cURL, Node config), but still the resource stats are missing.

Could you please check if there is any issue with the server monitoring service, Node integration, or API fetching system stats?

Please fix this as soon as possible.

Thank you.

This means you haven't set up Node.js correctly, so it's recommended to review the video appropriate for your hosting:
https://youtube.com/@magdalmuntaser/videos

44 minutes ago, KHOLIL DIGITAL said:

cannot access AI BOT..

Open the storage/logs/laravel.log file to find out exactly where the problem is.
If the laravel.log file is too large, you can remove it, then open the aibot page until the problem appears.
Then go back to the laravel.log file, it should now be there. Open it to identify the problem.

The fourth server has been added to the marketplace.
The marketplace now operates on 4 servers across different countries, distributed as follows:

• Singapore Server 1:
  Australia, Brunei, Cambodia, China, Indonesia, Japan, South Korea, Laos, Malaysia, Myanmar, Philippines, Russia, Singapore, Taiwan, Thailand
  
  

• United States Server:
  United States, Canada, Mexico, Guatemala, Belize, El Salvador, Honduras, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Panama, Bahamas, Cuba, Jamaica, Haiti, Dominican Republic, Trinidad and Tobago, Barbados, Antigua and Barbuda, Dominica, Saint Kitts and Nevis, Saint Lucia, Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, Grenada, Puerto Rico, Colombia, Venezuela, Ecuador, Peru, Brazil, Bolivia, Paraguay, Uruguay, Argentina, Chile, Guyana, Suriname
  
  

• India Server:
  Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal, Pakistan, Sri Lanka
  
  

• Germany Server:
  Rest of the world

======

There is also a United Kingdom server and (Singapore Server 2, which will operate alongside the first) still under preparation, and soon a Middle East server.

MPWA users are growing rapidly.
The next objective is to evolve this script from just a WhatsApp gateway into a gateway for all websites.

The plugin has been added to the (Marketplace).
You can install it if you wish from the Plugins page.

- Added DapuriX TapTask v1.0.1 (By DapuriX) - [ @MURASAKI. ] [To support DapuriX, click here].

Description: Turn your daily WhatsApp activity into actionable work. Forward a message or type a keyword and it instantly becomes a structured task on your board.

Screenshot:

=======



=======



=======



=======



=======

8 minutes ago, Magd Almuntaser said:

The plugin has been added to the (Marketplace).
You can install it if you wish from the Plugins page.

- Added DapuriX TapTask v1.0.1 (By DapuriX) - [ @MURASAKI. ] [To support DapuriX, click here].

Description: Turn your daily WhatsApp activity into actionable work. Forward a message or type a keyword and it instantly becomes a structured task on your board.

Screenshot:

=======



=======



=======



=======



=======

Gud job brother @MURASAKI. 😘

DapuriX TapTask v1.0.1

3 minutes ago, ADS SOLUTIONS said:

DapuriX TapTask v1.0.1

May i know what region do you acces and what fallback from the log?

First, maybe you can restart nodejs and apache/nginx and reinstall again.

40 minutes ago, ADS SOLUTIONS said:

DapuriX TapTask v1.0.1

Fixed .. the problem was that the plugin wasn't automatically migrated to the Indian server, but that issue has been fixed.
You can now install the plugin.

Now working sir @Magd Almuntaser